The Wrap that the image is authentic, noting that a digitized version of the yearbook is online. The college representative said they couldn’t ascertain whether Carlson asked to have the organizations listed or if someone else put them in.
There is no mention of the Dan White Society elsewhere in the yearbook, so it may not have been a real organization, or at least not a school-sanctioned one.
There is an organization based in North Carolina called the Jesse Helms Center, which describes itself as “a non-profit, non-political foundation which provides quality educational lectures, training schools and events focused on the principles of our founding fathers, traditional American values and the causes which United States Senator Jesse Helms.