Andy Cohen is not buying the Real Housewives of Salt Lake City star Heather Gay’s story about how she got that infamous black eye!
During an episode of Watch What Happens Live on Wednesday, the 54-year-old host asked guest Lala Kent who she thought hurt Heather, and she seemed to support the fan theory that Jen Shah was responsible for the incident!
The Vanderpump Rules responded: Andy then made his thoughts on who was behind Heather’s injuries very clear, saying: Related: Why Jen Refused Interview With Ex-Boss Andy Cohen! For those who don’t know, the drama surrounding the 40-year-old personality’s shiner played out during season 3 of RHOSLC.
Heather woke up one day during a cast trip to San Diego sporting a badly bruised eye – and allegedly had no idea how it happened!